Chief Justice of India Surya Kant on Friday declined to order separate listing of an application seeking recall of the order that referred the challenge to the 2023 election commissioners' appointment law to a Constitution bench, saying the plea can be raised before the five-judge bench already constituted to hear the matter.
The development came when advocate Prashant Bhushan mentioned the recall application before the CJI, noting that one of the two judges who passed the September 23 order was retiring next week. He urged that the application be listed before the same two-judge bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sharma, which had heard the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
The CJI said the five-judge Constitution bench could consider the recall application even if one of the judges who passed the original order had retired by then. "Let the matter come before the larger bench. You can raise this plea, and let us see what it will do," the CJI told Bhushan. Justice Joymalya Bagchi, a member of the bench led by the CJI, told Bhushan that the five-judge bench could consider the validity of the reference order and entertain his objections. When Bhushan pointed out that Justice Sharma would have retired by the time the matter came up before the Constitution bench, the CJI responded that recall applications are listed even after a judge has retired.
The September 23 judgment saw a divergence between Justices Datta and Sharma on whether the challenge to the 2023 law required consideration by a Constitution bench. Justice Datta held that a larger bench was unnecessary, while Justice Sharma held that the matter raised substantial constitutional questions warranting a five-judge bench. The two judges eventually agreed to place the matter before the CJI for constitution of a larger bench. The recall application was filed by Naman Sherstra, one of the petitioners, and seeks recall of Justice Sharma's opinion and the common order on the ground that the judge ought to have disclosed a possible conflict of interest and recused himself. The application alleges that Justice Sharma's son appears for the Election Commission of India before the Madhya Pradesh high court.
