The Delhi High Court has directed the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) to compensate the families of two boys who died after falling into an open sewer at a public park in Pitampura in April 2010. In a ruling released on November 18, a bench of Justice Jasmeet Singh held that authorities maintaining public parks owe a heightened duty of care towards children, who cannot anticipate potential hazards as adults would.
The court directed the two bodies to pay ₹11.01 lakh to each family, along with 9% annual interest from the date of filing of the petitions, and ₹1 lakh each towards litigation costs. It said all citizens have a right to visit the park and, as a corollary, the DJB and DDA are obligated to ensure visitors' safety. The court held that negligence was clear on the part of both authorities, noting that as public authorities performing public functions they owe a duty of care to citizens.
The verdict came on petitions filed by the parents of the two boys, who were about 11.5 years and 12.9 years old at the time of the accident, seeking ₹10,00,000 each. The DDA submitted that although the park falls under its jurisdiction, the civil works were executed under DJB supervision, so no negligence could be attributed to it. The DJB argued that the open sewer/manhole was duly protected by RCC walls of about 4 to 5 feet in height.
The court rejected both claims, holding that the presence of an open sewer or manhole in a public park imposes a heightened duty of care on the authority responsible for its maintenance. It observed that children, owing to their tender age and limited foresight, may perceive inadequately secured pits as objects of curiosity rather than threats to their lives, and cannot be blamed for their inability to recognise such dangers. The responsible authority was obligated to ensure the park was protected from all kinds of untoward incidents, which it failed to do, the court said.
