The Supreme Court on Wednesday said it would examine whether it had been misled after learning that a World War II veteran, in whose favour it had upheld a war injury pension order, had died in January 2019 — nearly two years before the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) granted him the pension. A bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justice SVN Bhatti directed the Army to make every effort to ascertain the legal heirs of ex-rifleman Govind Singh Rawat, and asked the Senior Superintendent of Police and the station house officer concerned to assist Army officials in identifying them. The court sought a report from the Army when the matter is next heard, saying, "If fraud has been played on court, we have to detect it." Notice was issued on a review petition by the Centre, the Chief of Army Staff and others seeking recall of an October 17, 2023, judgment dismissing the Centre's appeal against the grant of pension.
The appeal had been dismissed over a 457-day delay in challenging the Lucknow bench of the AFT's order of June 4, 2021, granting Rawat the war injury pension, with arrears restricted to three years before he approached the tribunal on September 9, 2020. It was while implementing the order that the Army learnt Rawat had died on January 17, 2019, and that the petition before the AFT was filed by subedar major and honorary captain Gamal Singh Rawat. Additional solicitor general Archana Pathak Dave told the court that the death certificate was on record but the legal heirs were unknown, and that the petitioner had been represented by a lawyer throughout the tribunal proceedings; the Army learnt of the death only when it sought bank details and cancelled cheques to comply with the AFT order.
The Army confirmed from its records that Gamal Singh Rawat and Govind Singh Rawat were not related, though Gamal had supplied his bank details to receive the pension benefits. The Centre's petition, citing the death certificate as a new and vital fact, said it pertained to "an act of probable fraud being played by a person (Gamal Singh Rawat) for obtaining a judicial verdict on behalf of the respondent (Govind Singh Rawat)." The court asked why the Army had not verified the fact at the earliest stage, remarking that the petitioner's advocate was present, not he, and noted that military intelligence could have been useful. The Army said it had received no information about Rawat's death before his service records were destroyed in 2000.
Rawat was enrolled in the Army's Royal Garhwal Rifles regiment in September 1941, before Independence, and was invalidated out of service on April 6, 1947. His service rolls showed he was injured in a battle in Italy during the Second World War. More than 63 years after being invalidated out, he approached the Garhwal Rifles regiment in 2011 for the war injury element. The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), Allahabad, returned his claim as "unactioned", saying the pension could be claimed only by soldiers killed or disabled in the wars of 1971, 1965, 1962 or the 1947-48 operations. The rejection order was issued on June 26, 2020, and communicated to Rawat in July 2020, after which he filed a petition before the AFT.
